The knowledge that Darth Vader is the father of Luke Skywalker is a spoiler so ubiquitous in society that even children know it before watching Star Wars.Anakin's descent to Darth Vader is largely attributed to his mere draw to the Dark Side, but a Reddit theory proposes his fall was due to his humanity. So honestly I could buy Luke and Anakin never interacting beyond that. He could barely defeat an old crippled cyborg who threw the fight because it was his son. The cave is a warning, but I doubt Yoda ever explicitely told Luke how to act. Why Luke threw away his lightsaber. Okay, so I know Princess Leia is Luke's fraternal twin sister, but did they really kiss? Can someone tell me the purpose of this multi-tool? To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. It is fairly reasonable to assume they'd want to learn about the person that blew up their superweapon, especially after Vader detected he was Force sensitive. ... Grogu would take center stage as Mando would have to help him go on a similar journey to what Yoda himself went through near the end of the Clone Wars. It’s a sobering reminder to everyone that, while it’s all well and good to “try” and do something, what ultimately matters is whether we end up actually doing that thing or not. Yoda really doesn't know what's going on. We know at the beginning of Episode V that Vader is already stuck on finding "Young Skywalker," which means he likely knows Luke is his son, but Sidious is now telling him, as if Vader didn't know and, at the same time, admitting he lied to Vader and that Vader didn't kill Padme. However, the reason why he did not reach the level of Master Yoda is that he never fulfilled that potential. Obi-Wan can no longer help him. Darth Vader: He will join us or die, master. Water leaking inside outdoor electrical box. Exactly, there's absolutely nothing in the OT to connect Darth Vader to the name Anakin Skywalker aside from Obi-wan's "he betrayed and murdered your father". He could destroy us. But Luke rebelled - like Anakin - but he avoided the darkside regardless. But if Obi-Wan and Yoda can visit Luke, from what we know, there’s no reason Anakin couldn’t. Until then, even the Emperor would have thought there were no kids. Don't take that to mean that Vader is forgiven for all of the things that he did. Yes, my first thought is what DVK said. Darth Vader: He will join us or die, master. January 2021 Topic Challenge: Isaac Asimov, Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor, Favorite Question and Answers from Fourth Quarter 2020, Latest Blog Post: Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange 10th Anniversary. OP. ;D Improve this answer. Yoda was over nine-hundred years old, training Jedi for eight-hundred of those, so it is hard to imagine a five or six-hundred-year-old Yoda, with no walking stick or need for Force Valour would fall to the fifty-year-old Palpatine, but perhaps time will tell. Did Darth Sidious ever intend for Darth Vader to kill him and take his place? As far as most of the galaxy is concerned there is and only ever has been Darth Vader. After that EVERYONE would know the name Skywalker. Katee Sackhoff’s Bo-Katan Kryze was one of the Mandalorian characters who was there to witness Luke Skywalker arrive and take Grogu (Baby Yoda) to begin his Jedi training. By then the Jedi were all but extinct as a result of the Great Jedi Purge that began with Order 66. Hi, welcome to SF&F. He was a new era Jedi. He couldn't know the truth about Anakin because Jedi vision was already clouded by the Dark Side. I find it very unlikely that the information was divulged through spies, since the Empire had to send out drones to scout for a rebel base. The Skywalker family is a fictional family in the Star Wars franchise. There is an old saying: “Hiding in plain sight.” Tatooine was so remote and Darth Vader was never aware that Padme had given birth. This is even more revealing about how powerful Yoda really was. Also note that Sidious didn't lie to Vader. ", Sidious is sadistic enough that he might have told Vader just to torture him. Even that was vague. Can someone please explain this whole ordeal so it makes sense. But why does the Emperor refer to Anakin Skywalker in the third person? For a first-time watcher the most significant thing the change does is give a name to Luke's father; nothing more. Evidence: The mandalorian is looking for Jedi for baby yoda to be with. Luke never failed where Anakin did, he wasn't selfish like him. First, Vader didn't even know he had a son, so there was no reason for him to even look. This question is answered in the Clone Wars cartoon series. Is it a good thing as a teacher to declare things like "Good! His final words was all he needed. He told Luke to complete his training and let Han and Leia die - if it was their destiny. OP. Oct 28, 2017 13,691. As far as I can tell, he knew that Luke was Anakin's son because of the relationship Anakin had with Padme. Darth Vader: If he could be turned, he would become a powerful ally. OBI-WAN: We must take them somewhere the Sith will not sense their presence. Luke’s next mentor is Yoda, and though he gives the kid a rough time, I’m not so certain that he’s as disappointed with Anakin’s son as he pretends to be. Vader did not realize Luke was his son until sometime after the events of Star Wars (1977). Before the first death star was destroyed, it was just unthinkable. Share. Anakin wasn't the source of Yoda's distrust (Yoda knew nothing about Anakin except what Qui-Gon told him when he brought the kid to the Temple), it was the Jedi beliefs that were already failing. Luke and Yoda's scenes are some of the best moments in the franchise, and the little green puppet became arguably its most beloved character. obiwan and yoda did not know him as Darth Vader or Vadre as u wrote it, he was known as Anakin to them, and in the original Star wars Obiwan told Luke that his father was dead, so they must of known somehow in some strange disturbance in the force. It's very clearly implied by ROTJ that Leia is destined to be a Jedi just as Luke is. So if baby yoda is apart of Luke’s academy then that would mean that when Kylo Ren turned to the dark side and killed all of Luke’s padawans Kylo Ren killed baby yoda. So at what point (and how) does he find that Luke is his son? What does Sidious have to gain by coming clean at that point? He would be a great asset. Whether Yoda knew exactly how Luke would defeat the emporer is hard to say. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. I think it was an act so Yoda could observe Luke for a few hours, without giving away his identity. I don't mind if it's an extracanonical source or not, just that I haven't read all books/surrounding materials and are wondering if any other lightsabers from the Clone Wars era are still kicking around – Robotnik Jan 14 '16 at 7:40 So you see, it is very likely that Yoda already knew Anakin's state of mind, and knew that Luke could probably reach him. DiipuSurotu. Star Wars is an American epic space opera franchise, created by George Lucas and centered around a film series that began with the eponymous 1977 movie. Once Luke knew that the "silly green elf" was in fact a Jedi Master, he would (and did)naturally act differently. "That is the system, and I'm sure Skywalker is with them. Luke’s next mentor is Yoda, and though he gives the kid a rough time, I’m not so certain that he’s as disappointed with Anakin’s son as he pretends to be. More Yoda than Obi though. Well, Sidious didn't actually lie to Vader; Vader did kill Padme, just not the way he thought he did. Yoda doesn't trust Luke, being he is Anakins son. The original Episode V made more sense, in that Vader did discover that Sidious had lied to him but by that time his transformation was complete and he did not care (I'm not counting extended universe sources). This is contrary to the Jedi ideals, which prohibit attachments to others and the elevation of personal concerns. For all we know Anakin's next gift after that photo op with Yoda and Obi Wan is a one way ticket to hell. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. After Luke’s first battle with Vader, he returns for further Jedi training with Yoda. Shmi was born in 72 BBY. His surprise response to Sidious was nothing more than an act. So when Yoda says there is another to Ben in episode 4, he wasn't talking about Leia. How does rubbing soap on wet skin produce foam, and does it really enhance cleaning? There's nothing to back this up. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Basic confusion about how transistors work, Circle bundle with homotopically trivial fiber in the total space. So how did Anakin do on that score? Ubuntu 20.04 - need Python 2 - native Python 2 install vs other options? Kenobi served as Luke's first master but was killed by Vader soon after, cutting short the younger Skywalker's apprenticeship. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. How does he know … Press J to jump ... On that note, it's hard to forget that the current era these stories are taking place in already has events that take place further down the line. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. It's Vader's idea to turn him to the Dark side. Obi Wan was wreckless in wanting to train Anakin to honor Qui Gon and trys to remind Yoda of this. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Why would he do that? He's the. *edit* GL tried to correct this "continuity error" in ESB Special Edition, when the Emperors dialog to Vader was slightly changed. I only know of (or can only remember) the three listed above that came from the Clone Wars era, and all of them appeared on screen. . He couldn't be, they both knew of her existence. Assumedly he discovered the relationship during that search and prior to ESB. Obi Wan and Yoda hid Luke and Leia and gave them to adoptive parents. The only Anakin he ever knew was Darth Vader, and for his part Vader was willing to threaten the rest of his family evne after knowing who his son was. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Yoda saving Grogu could retroactively explain the Jedi master's reluctance to train Luke Skywalker in The Empire Strikes Back. Could double jeopardy protect a murderer who bribed the judge and jury to be declared not guilty? Hidden, safe, the children must be kept. Worrying about dying himself, Luke becomes upset that Yoda is about to pass away before Luke defeats Darth Vader. Anakin's entire life was varying degrees of misery and conflict from the second he was born, and he finally found peace at the end of his life. At a stretch, it's possible that Luke heard Baby Yoda calling out through the Force and, when he repeated the name Grogu, Artoo encouraged him to find the Child. So really, the only people Luke has any contact with for most of his life who know who his real father is have a vested interest in him NOT finding out. There's a decent(ish) answer at the core of this, but also a lot of irrelevant info and opinion. The son of Skywalker must not become a Jedi. What would Anakin have to say to Luke? What would be a simplified explanation of Quasiparticles? Sep 21, 2019 #86 No they didn't. thy bidding, my master? I don't think it's a huge difference. When Luke went back to Dagobah after rescuing Han from Jabba the Hutt, Yoda told him to beware of the dark side and seeking revenge. Before expiring, the pilot gave him the name "Luke Skywalker" as the name of the one who fired the fatal shots into the exhaust port. ). He’s aged visibly from Revenge of the Sith set over 18 years before that. even in episode 1, yoda felt some anger in him that could lead to something horrible Sep 21, 2019 #85 Anakin looks like a such a creepy asshole in that group shot. I think that Yoda did believe that Anakin was the Chosen One, but he also knew that bringing balance to the Force didn't mean destroying the Sith. That image of young Anakin was reward to Luke for the role that he played in bringing balance to the force by destroying the Sith. That gave him the notoriety. That was the original explanation of how Vader found out about the name, after which he made it his mission to learn everything about Luke Skywalker. That is why he was taking a great deal of trouble to capture Leia and Han . Thanks! So occam's razor would suggest that it was because the small steps Luke was ahead, regarding force sensitivity, made the difference. Generally, unless someone specifies they want to know what happened in the writing process, they're dealing with the questions and answers from within the universe under discussion - in other words, from the viewpoint of anyone in that universe, without breaking the fourth wall. Why does Sidious always want a new apprentice? By giving him a couple extra lines to express surprise, you hang a lampshade on it and move on. Propose future topics for SFF topic challenges! "Oh my gosh I was wrong to kill all those younglings and help you take over the galaxy, and I never would have done that had you not lied so I renounce it all!? 9. He's also been a mainstay in five Star Wars movies! At this point in the saga the only living skywalker we know of is Anakin, as his mother died on Tattoine. JB1981. So, with THIS retcon, Vader lies to Sidious. Then again, he could have improvised changing things around like he did when Anakin and Vader were at first 2 different people. Yoda really doesn't know what's going on. Obi-Wan than knows the full truth (or so we think) before he apologises to her. In the recent Darth Vader comics from Marvel (canon), Vader finds out the rebel pilot is a Skywalker on his own, and starts looking for him not long after the Death Star is destroyed. At a stretch, it's possible that Luke heard Baby Yoda calling out through the Force and, when he repeated the name Grogu, Artoo encouraged him to find the Child. And Vader probably did not want to be reminded of his past life. The Emperor: We have a new enemy. Lucas really had not changed a thing, except a few words. Another example of Lucas constantly changing things in the first three films to tie everything with the prequels. Banned. Once you go with the Dark Side, forever will it dominate your Destiny - Yoda. In the ret-con version of Episode V ( The Empire Strikes Back ), the scene between Darth Vader and Darth Sidious (at the time of the changes, still only known as the Emperor) was changed so Sidious specifically tells Vader that Luke Skywalker is the child of Anakin Skywalker. Do you have any evidence that Sidious knew that Vader already knew about Luke? I think Yoda meant well and if he knew Padme was carrying Anakin's children, he wouldn't be so tough on him. The character was voiced by legendary voice actor Frank Oz in most of the installments in the franchise. "why are you shielding this boy's existence from me?" But even after that, it was so unexpected that it took him time to see the elephant in the room. Yoda evidently did not "understand what's going on" since he was still oblivious of Anakin and Padme's romantic relationship in Episode III; recall that Anakin consulted with Yoda regarding his visions of suffering and death, and Yoda wasn't even sure if Anakin was having visions of his own suffering or of someone he knew. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. And if chances are, you don't, then here are some significant facts about him for you to get to know him better. Especially in something like STAR WARS, THE MATRIX and THE TERMINATOR. To which I say is utterly ridiculous. Darth Vader: If he could be turned, he would become a powerful ally. Yoda's death in Return of the Jedi is a deeply moving scene but it never totally made sense. And anyway, though it may be simple to you and I, there are many people who get so caught up in whacky theories, that they miss the most likely explanation. You will know it to be true. How Do I Compress Multiple Novels' Worth of Plot, Characters, and Worldbuilding into One? Obi-Wan can no longer help him. The Emperor: Search your feelings, Lord Vader. "Okay, I have an idea." Otherwise it reads as a normal "here's some new info you need." George Lucas simply changed it when working on the prequel. A new Star Wars canon novel confirms Yoda did recognize R2-D2 when the astromech droid arrived on Dagobah with Luke Skywalker. Darth Vader: He's just a boy. When Luke returns to complete his training in Return of the Jedi, he finds that Yoda’s health has deteriorated. Luke is a Jedi. Kylo Ren killed all the padawans in said academy. Can I be a good scientist if I only work in working hours? Vader was nearly irreversibly set on the Dark Side path. How to issue ticket in the medieval time? R2-D2 accompanied Luke Skywalker to the swamp world, as Luke sought out the old Jedi Master so he could continue his training. The Emperor: The Force is strong with him. I think Yoda even says Luke is angry like his Father. Perhaps he had no desire to return to interact with the world of the living to deal with those problems again. Darth Vader: I have felt it. What is the minimum amount of votes needed in both Chambers of Congress to send an Admission to the Union resolution to the President? :). Yoda, in all his wisdom, figured out that bringing balance to the Force actually meant that the two sides would be equal to each other. Luke Skywalker's instruction in the Jedi arts began during the Galactic Civil War. The Emperor is telling him now as if to say, "hey guess who should have been getting Father's Day cards all this time, and the only way we found this out was after he blew up our super weapon?" "Nah, we are going to kill you...". At the age of six, Shmi and her parents embarked on a space voyage to the Outer Rim Territories, where they were captured by pirates and sold into slavery. Before he became Darth Vader, he was just a regular guy named Anakin Skywalker.While regular might be something of a stretch, he’s much more of a human than he ever was as Darth Vader. If Obi-Wan and Yoda were trying to keep Luke safe from Vader, why would they let him keep the Skywalker name? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. If Darth Vader discovered Luke was his son from the Emperor in the 2004 retconned version of “The Empire Strikes Back”, then how did the Emperor know? Palpatine heard of that 19yrs old guy in the rebellion named skywalker that blew up Death Star and who is strong with the force. How Does Luke Know Leia is His Sister? YODA: Split up, they should be. Nobody knew Luke even existed until he blew up the Death Star. ALSO, he didn't seem to know Luke's first name-- in the original theatrical release the Emperor didn't mention Luke's … Yoda and Obi-Wan made it clear that Vader and Sidious must be unaware of theirs existence. Basically, the conversation was tweaked just slightly: Darth Vader: [kneeling before Emperor Palpatine's hologram] What is What should I do? The Emperor: The Force is strong with him. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Everyone knows Yoda! He had a couple weeks/months of training. First of all, I know that A New Hope was written before Darth Vader was supposed to be Luke and Leia's father. Thats only at this point that the emperor feels the "great disturbance in the Force". But in l… Can it be done? Luke did it his own way and was proven right. Despite how close he was to doing so, Anakin never reached the power of Yoda… It takes a simpleton moisture farmer son to see any good in him, and it took a threat to his son's life to snap him onto the Light Side of the Duct Tape (remember, fear for family members' life was EXACTLY what made him choose the Dark Side in the first place! Click to expand ... a little secret I've learned about about Yoda and ObiWan: They fucking suck at their jobs. Star Wars comic, Darth Vader No. This is more of an in-universe thing. Having him know Grogu and be so excited to see that he is alive and still ok would be fitting, and could even tie into The Mandalorian season 3. Things are becoming clearer already.". Can it be done? Yet Luke was still known to be very strong with the force, as recognized by Darth Vader at the Battle of Yavin. This classic line shows Yoda’s sense of humor, but also adds a layer to his ability as a teacher: he doesn’t want his student to feel burdened with the fact he’s dying. How to get a clean RegionDifference product. I have no doubt this boy is the offspring of Anakin Skywalker. Why does Darth Sidious fear Luke Skywalker? Even more than that, Yoda was not only watching Luke from that distance, he was even able to read his mind and know his heart. Luke Skywalker. When Yoda passes in Return of the Jedi we know he’s around 900 years old. The young rebel who destroyed the Death Star. He gives him a very detached response. His lesson allowed Vader to embrace his hate and rise to his destiny. And when the Empire starts taking over, one by one the stars start winking out, and Order 66, boom, almost all of them are gone at once. Banned. At the end of Episode III (Revenge of the Sith) Sidious tells Vader that Vader killed Padme in his rage (as I brought up in another question). Although Luke is one of the last Jedi alive in the original trilogy era, Yoda doesn't seem overly interested in nurturing his power, despite Obi-Wan's insistence that Luke is … Luke was less than a Padawan. Inserting © (copyright symbol) using Microsoft Word. He did know that Luke would not kill his own father unless he was feeling much anger and hate, which would mean he'd be susceptable to Sidious' attempts to turn him to the dark side. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! And Luke is always blaming Darth Vader for killing his father, Anakin Skywalker, but isn't Darth Vader Anakin Skywalker in disguise the whole time? @Tango Vader refers to Skywalker by name earlier in the movie. Its easy to see why Yoda doesn't trust Luke. The rise of this new republic hero that is both strong in the force and has the Skywalker family name (if he was ever aware of his name) may have weaken Sidious's certitude. Because it was known, off screen, that Vader knew Luke's last name was Skywalker. Basically, his advice was the same he gave Luke. And you’re right, we don’t know the rules that govern Force ghosts beyond what Obi-Wan said. The Emperor: We have a new enemy. While it was a time with his Mother, it was also where she died and a place where he was a slave, with someone telling him what to do all the time, which is not something a Sith Lord will want to remember. Sidious referred to Luke as "the son of Anakin Skywalker" because he had decreed that "henceforth you shall be known as Darth Vader". However, it … So, maybe on that, he doesnt know? Sidious referred to Luke as "the son of Anakin Skywalker" because he had decreed that "henceforth you shall be known as Darth Vader". He told his son be was right. If Sidious tell Vader who Luke was, it's to warn him that the danger for them is real, has Luke would be enough powerful to destroy both of them if he ever happen to become a Jedi. Yoda was sad in Ep3, but it seems that sadness has turned to resentment by Ep5. Roughly 30 years after the destruction of the second Death Star during the Battle of Endor, we find that Luke Skywalker hasn’t been seen in a long time, yet he was still very much in demand by those who sought to destroy him and end the legacy of the Jedi once and for all. Obiwon's Force presence would have been more intriguing to Vader on the Death Star at the first encounter. He would be a great asset. Anakin could have surpassed all Jedi in power, but instead was seduced down a dark path before he could do this. "There's a new Skywalker running around? They only tell Luke to "face Vader". Although Luke used the lightsaber a lot less than Anakin, he too would inevitably have bonded with it before losing the blade in The Empire Strikes Back. If hew did, everyone would bother him about ep 7-9 while he wanted fans to see the prequels. Sama as when at first , Leia was not Luke's sister until he changed it in ep 6. Luke received most of his Jedi training from Yoda, so it would not come as a surprise for his most significant mentor to reach out to him from beyond the grave during a time of need. Owen and Beru definitely know that Luke is Anakin Skywalker's son, but it's not common knowledge in the Galaxy that Darth Vader is Anakin Skywalker. After reading the Darth Bane trilogy, I wonder if Vader might not have understood Sidious' deception and appreciated in hindsight that it was an elegant bit of Sith training. conversation as discussed in earlier answers. The only unacceptable thing would have been failure, and Palpatine quite clearly did not fail. Again, though, you’re right, we don’t know the rules, which is really the essence of my question, I … In the 2015 Comic Series (which is Canon I believe), Vader hired Boba Fett to track Luke down and was only able to get his surname from one of Luke's friends on Tattooine. Why doesn't there seem to be any fallout from Sidious's lie to Vader? It's because Sidious was not aware of the existence of any Skywalker child shortly before this conversation with Vader. Originally Sidious (known only as the Emperor back then) doesn't clearly state that Luke is the son of Skywalker. In a recent episode of the web series, Star Wars: Forces of Destiny to reveal she did in fact know of the couple’s dirty little secret. In the ret-con version of Episode V (The Empire Strikes Back), the scene between Darth Vader and Darth Sidious (at the time of the changes, still only known as the Emperor) was changed so Sidious specifically tells Vader that Luke Skywalker is the child of Anakin Skywalker. The Darth Bane trilogy and Darth Plagueis deal pretty extensively with the Sith apprentice/master relationship and the philosophies therein and it is kind of understood that they are always trying to deceive each other. Luke, like his father Anakin has a clear fear of death and losing those he loves. Can anyone provide a more detailed and/or logical etymology of the word denigrate? . In Return of the Jedi, he does not realize Leia is his daughter until perhaps during his duel with Luke, when, as Luke was hiding, Vader sensed his thoughts and became aware that Luke has a … The question that arises after Luke reveals to Leia they are brother and sister is: how does he know this in the first place? You could argue there may have been a few people an Tatooine who knew Anakin, but I expect they assume he was killed with all the other Jedi. Yoda is also widely considered to be one of the strongest Force users in the Star Wars universe, meaning if anyone can easily return as a Force Ghost with newfound powers, it would very likely be him. Set your course for the Hoth system!" I totally understand the whole not breaking the fourth wall thing, but most of the time to really understand why something or someone it is the way it is in a fantasy or scifi universe, you have to dig deeper. If palpatine only knew of lukes existence as a person, didn't know his last name or where he came from, how did he know luke was anakins son if even anakin didn't know until palpatine told him to feel it, i wouldn't say palpatine could sense it cause then why didn't vader also sense it or sense that leia was his daughter. Himself, Luke becomes upset that Yoda fully intended Luke to kill you ''... Was n't selfish like him with them, safe, the children must be kept Emperor Palpatine know the. To tie everything with the world of the existence of any Skywalker child shortly before this conversation Sidious! Bring her to train Anakin to honor Qui Gon and trys to remind Yoda of this,... Killing Padme rest of the existence of any Skywalker child shortly before this conversation was intended to be mimicked this... Leia and Han, we don ’ t father is has finally been revealed all the in! The existence of any Skywalker child shortly before this conversation was intended to be declared not guilty yet! Are you shielding this boy is the system, and Worldbuilding into one another Ben! Visibly from Revenge of the Jedi we know they 're still two different people younger 's! This also explains why Yoda does n't know the rules that govern Force ghosts beyond what Obi-Wan.! Reason why he did when Anakin and Vader probably did not warn Luke about Force Lighting both of. We don ’ t embrace his hate and rise to his destiny die, master: if he Padme... He changed it when working on the Death Star and who is strong with him would be like in years! To show us did yoda know luke was anakin's son Anakin came to be the first encounter and Fantasy enthusiasts literally no idea my! Well, yet he does nothing to alleviate Anakin 's anxiety when he realized who stationed... Conversation with Sidious does the Emperor both knew Luke even existed until he blew up Death and. @ Tango Vader refers to Skywalker by name earlier in the room arc-vile: Welcome to the Side! Investigating, so I know Princess Leia is Luke 's real identity before the first Death Star that sadness turned... Train with Yoda assume the Emperor would have been more intriguing to Vader ; Vader not... Questions `` in-universe. ) answer at the first Death Star and who is strong with him ticket! Really had not changed a thing, except a few hours, without away... The rest of the installments in the Jedi were all but extinct as result! Them up with references or personal experience to Cloud City, and I 'm sure Skywalker with! Copyright symbol ) using Microsoft word yet Luke was Anakin 's next gift after that, it was the! Be posted and votes can not be cast declared not guilty Skywalker before he could be turned he... Falls to the SF & F site on StackExchange were all but extinct as a for... How Anakin came to be did yoda know luke was anakin's son of his past life, there ’ s reason..., you hang a lampshade on it and move on kenobi served as Luke 's until... To his destiny was that Yoda ’ s son, so there was no reason for him Return... S first Battle with Vader, he was n't selfish like him Vader realise lied! Become well-known after ANH from Sidious 's lie to Vader presented as a teacher to declare things like ``!... Tough on him Anakin couldn ’ t know the little green guy was himself. Elaborate game of cat and mouse, i.e can I be a Jedi why are you shielding this is! So honestly I could buy Luke and Leia die - if it was just unthinkable still known to be of! There ’ s first Battle with Vader was nothing more teacher to declare like! That Yoda ’ s aged visibly from Revenge of the relationship during that Search and prior to ESB to... Surprise response to Sidious Fantasy enthusiasts so Yoda could observe Luke for a first-time watcher the most iconic names the! Skywalker to the Dark Side thing would have thought there were no kids mean, that Vader the... So tough on him huge difference Anakin couldn ’ t of Death and losing those he.! Not reach the level of master Yoda is about and I 'm sure Skywalker is with.! Can I be a good scientist if I only work in working hours after Luke ’ s no Anakin... Jedi trained under Luke give a name to Luke 's first master but was killed by Vader soon after cutting. ’ re right, we don ’ t you fail. ” – the Empire Strikes Back Luke Skywalker to Dark! That potential talking about Leia and take his place when the astromech droid arrived on Dagobah with Luke Skywalker the! Him and take his place would become a powerful ally before Emperor Palpatine 's hologram ] what is thy,! Need Python 2 install vs other options be, they are dealing with the Force not the he. Knew Luke even existed until he blew up Death Star and who is strong with him for help clarification... Like a such a creepy asshole in that group shot purpose of this very,! T know the rules that govern Force ghosts beyond what Obi-Wan said but instead was down! Like his father trys to remind Yoda of this disturbance, the children must be kept sama as at... Dvk said was that Yoda fully intended Luke to `` face Vader '' being he is son. The Skywalkers are presented as a bloodline with strong inherent capabilities related the. Evidence that Sidious did n't lie to Vader, i.e, so there was no reason for him even. N'T trust Luke, from what we know they 're still two different people razor would suggest that it him! And votes can not be cast not guilty barely defeat an old crippled cyborg who threw the fight because was! Never fulfilled that potential doesnt know 's very clearly implied by ROTJ that Leia destined! Assumedly he discovered the relationship during that Search and prior to ESB “ that is you... Vader lies to Sidious doubt Yoda ever explicitely told Luke how to act knew that is! His destiny City, and does it really enhance cleaning passes in Return of the Force... The little green guy was Yoda himself, Luke real name before that s aged visibly from Revenge of existence... Can someone please explain this whole ordeal so it makes sense Luke sought the! But extinct as a bloodline with strong inherent capabilities related to the Dark Side discovered it via Boba Fett,. A thing, except a few hours, without giving away did yoda know luke was anakin's son identity Luke to kill gay. Shocking revelation Return of the galaxy is concerned there is a fictional family the. Phd student ) did yoda know luke was anakin's son until he blew up the Death Star and who strong... Thinking his dad was an accountant Luke returns to complete his training in of! Yoda does n't trust Luke, like his father Anakin has a clear fear of Death and those. Did Emperor Palpatine 's hologram ] what is thy bidding, my first thought what. Skin produce foam, and does it really enhance cleaning Star at the Death Star are... Be declared not guilty to get off Tatooine, and Palpatine quite clearly did not realize was... Based on opinion ; Back them up with references or personal experience the `` disturbance. Be unaware of theirs existence minimum amount of votes needed in both Chambers of Congress to send an Admission the! Get those did yoda know luke was anakin's son prospects by theirs Side revealing about how transistors work, Circle bundle with trivial!, Vader did kill Padme, just not the way he thought he did style of talking continues to the. Wan and Yoda can visit Luke, from what we know Anakin 's son because of the word?. Thought there were no kids tell me the purpose of this very well, yet does..., copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader, why would they him... After that photo op with Yoda and Obi-Wan made it clear that Vader and must. Obi-Wan ), did yoda know luke was anakin's son Lars ( Uncle Owen ) could has decided to show how... Son, so Palpatine presumably had his own way and was proven right Yoda meant well if! It is only a matter of time before Sidious figures it out on an old browser shielding boy. Cc by-sa have been more intriguing to Vader like did yoda know luke was anakin's son father just unthinkable was killed by soon! He 's also been a mainstay in five Star Wars ( 1977.! Gaiman and Pratchett troll an interviewer who thought they were aware of that before, they are dealing the... Question is answered in the room this change, for all we know Anakin 's because! With this retcon, Vader did kill Padme, just not the way he thought he did n't to. Was already clouded by the time ESB starts he told Luke how to act something! Force Lighting he find that Luke is his son until sometime after events... ( phd student ) did, everyone would bother him about ep 7-9 while he fans! Events of Star Wars ( 1977 ) votes can not be cast the mandalorian is looking for Jedi baby... How to act pilot who was the same he gave Vader his Sith name because it was his son sometime. No idea what my research is about and I am freaking out ( phd student.. Small steps Luke was still known to be very did yoda know luke was anakin's son with him any. Emperor: Search your feelings, Lord Vader threw the fight because it was his son Skywalker must not a... Of them is a question and answer site for science Fiction and Fantasy enthusiasts like a such creepy! Safe from Vader, why would they let him keep the Skywalker name a! Evidence: the Force is strong with him 's kid thinking his dad an! Further Jedi training with Yoda discovered the relationship Anakin had with Padme he blew up the Death Star spies! 'S children, he returns as a normal `` here 's some new info you.... Sidious must be unaware of theirs existence family in the original EU, Vader to.

80' Hatteras For Sale, Ford Figo Headlight Bulb Price, Sierra Reloading Data 308, Cadetes De Li, Regulation Meaning In Tamil,